Cover Bands Are For Indie Snobs, Too

This is just a tribute

Gutterween Thursday show poster. (Image: The Gutter Bar/Submitted)

One thing I’m grateful about as I grow older is that my snob sense is disappearing. For one thing, I’m more than fine with dance-pop if the tunes are there.

As a reformed classic-rock fan who turned into an indie/punk fan, the whole idea of cover bands was something I stupidly turned my nose up for a while as something too bougie. I could stomach it at weddings, New Year’s celebrations but it wasn’t something I’d go out to see otherwise. Over time though, I could even occasionally appreciate the old warhorse songs that these groups would trot out for their kitsch appeal at least— I’ll even sing along to “Sweet Caroline” once in a while, even if I don’t wanna hear the Neil Diamond version ever again. Also I get a kick when I occasionally see funster cover group The Nerds (“not your typical wedding band”) at Jersey shore bars. Besides, I wrote about Steely Dan here recently and two of their cover bands gave me some great insights about their album, The Royal Scam.

Even then, the whole idea of wanting to see a group do the hits from decades past seemed like a waste of time otherwise. Part of the problem is that living in or near a big metropolis like NYC spoils you— most any act that tours the States will make a pit stop here, so you get to see ‘em.

I’ve had friends and family see cover bands and wondered why they wasted their money. But it makes sense if band is no more (Fabs, Zep) or if costs too much to pay for tix/food/parking in stadiums (Springsteen) or if the performers a little too ragged for you in their old age (Dylan) or maybe if your locale isn’t a tour-friendly area. I get the idea — if it makes fans happy, who the hell am I to tell ‘em how to enjoy themselves? It would be cool if they checked out some local and up-and-coming acts too but again, that’s sadly not for everyone, though I do try to encourage everyone to do that. And as my boss here points out, cover bands are helping to save live music biz now as you can see here and here. Plus, even an ultra hip band like Wednesday dressed as the Addams Family to do covers recently 

Even then, I’d heard about NYC shows around Halloween where local groups would perform entire sets of more well-known indie/punk bands and I swear that it actually took me a while to figure out what the whole idea was — these bands were ‘dressed up’ for Halloween as other bands, duh. It’s a fun, cool concept actually, but I still thought “why bother?” Many of the dress-up bands were doing sets for some groups that I had seen a bunch of times or are even still touring. Seemed goofy to me. But now I’m glad to admit that I was wrong.

The Gutter Bar in Brooklyn had been doing Halloween cover band shows for a few years and their 2025 edition had a System of a Down cover set (with special appearances/crowd moments by GWAR) and other local bands channeling Radiohead, Lady Gaga, Kacey Musgraves and Amy Winehouse. This past month, they had their free three-day Gutterween celebration on Halloween weekend. Friday had bands as the Distillers, Green Day, Creed, My Chemical Romance, Blink 182, Kendrick Lamar, QOTSA, Yeah Yeah Yeahs, Bad Bunny and Alice in Chains. Halloween was mostly diva night with bands as Amy Winehouse, Chappell Roan, Madonna, Selena, Sabrina Carpenter and Britney Spears, along with Oasis, Beastie Boys, Tom Petty and Prince for some variety. Thursday night (see the poster above) was more my speed so I thought, “Why the hell not?” With two stages, they were able to squeeze 10 bands in for the night with groups alternating between the two places where one band would finish and the other band would start up right away on the other stage. 

(And the Gutter Bar wasn’t the only place for this — NYC venues such as Rubulad, Cassette, Bowery Palace, Sugar Mouse, Young Ethel’s and the Broadway all had Halloween cover shows last month, too, including everything from Modest Mouse to Siouxsie to Rush to Arcade Fire to The Zombies to Avril Lavigne)

As far as cover shows, I’d seen the Black Rock Coalition do Sly and the Family Stone’s There’s A Riot Goin’ On album front-to-back in 2024 and it was a freakin’ revelation about how much joy is actually buried in that wonderfully brutal record. I wondered if or when I’d see another show that could change my whole way of thinking like that. Gutterween managed to do that and I’m grateful for it. On top of that, to add to the entertainment, a number of the acts provided some inexplicable mysteries and confusion about them, as you’ll see below.

 

Mixed State as Bikini Kill (Image: Jason Gross)

RIOT JAZZ IS A REALITY

What better way to start off a night than a group parading on stage as Bikini Kill? Appropriately decked out as witches, Mixed State were stunning, doing riot grrl with a freakin’ neck-mounted violin. Try to imagine that with the roaring rage of “Suck My Left One,” “Reject All American,” “Blood One” or “Demirep“ (which included the kiddie rhyme intro). Better yet, you can relive some of these moments through a Facebook post that the band did with some videos of their set and tell me if you don’t think that they kicked ass and took names.

Now here’s the strange part (other than the violin). From their Facebook page, you can look up more info about the band and find out that they’re… a jazz act??? It’s true— they call themselves “electro-acoustic” but they’re just nice, low-key music in their other life. See their webpage for proof and check out this video also. You gotta be impressed that a band can put on two very different musical hats like that and pull it off well. Still, I wish they’d show their grrl side more. Makes you wonder how many other cover bands can do that. Not too many I’d think, but I’d love to be wrong.

 

Things On Fire as the Pixies (Image: Jason Gross)

FRANK-LESS PIXIES

Things on Fire were another interesting case of a unique cover group. AFAIK, they exist to do Pixies songs and live their lives otherwise as the indie band WifeKnife. A twist is that veil-outfitted singer Sarah Hamilton doesn’t try to be Frank Black and only one guitarist (J.R. Corominas, dressed as a pumpkin) is on deck. The thing is, they proved that you didn’t need a dude yelling the lyrics and one guitar worked just fine for the music and ultimately it’s Frank’s songs that carry the group, who never pretended to be virtuosos. “Wave of Mutilation,” “Alison” and “Where Is My Mind” didn’t just sound fine but inspired many sing-a-longs, including from me I admit. Plus, they had the added bonus of having a demon on bass and Beetlejuice on drums for the festivities —  something that Frank and Co. can’t brag of.

 

Weird Children as Joy Division/New Order (Image: Jason Gross)

A TRIPLE COVER BAND?

Weird Children pretending to Joy Division/New Order was an interesting choice — the setlist included “Transmission,” “Disorder” from the Joy Division catalog and “Age of Content” from New Order, plus “Ceremony” which was a song from both bands, but better known in the New Order version. The singer tried to do the Ian Curtis voice and wasn’t bad but let’s face it— only Ian could do Ian, even with New Order itself tacking on Joy Division songs into their sets since the late ‘90s. What occurred to me that didn’t before was that Joy Division itself was actually transitioning somewhat into New Order even before Ian sadly ended it all — listen again to the dance beats and synths of Closer and their last singles for proof. No doubt if Ian did survive, the lyrics would have been bleaker though. Also, with Hook exiled and now Stephen and Gillian out of the picture, New Order may still tour, but it’ll be Bernard and friends going forward.

Now here’s what was really strange about Weird Children — I tried to research them and I still can’t figure out who the hell they actually are. There was a Brooklyn band by that name from their early 2010’s that didn’t last long but if you look at their website, it looks like a totally different group. So… was this Weird Children band a tribute not only to Joy Division/New Order but also to the other Weird Children? Weird, ain’t it?

 

Bastards of Young as The Replacements (Image: Jason Gross)

THE ‘MATS REPLACEMENTS

Bastards of Young helped sow more confusion for the night. They were masquerading as the Replacements but this cover band ain’t the punk band from San Francisco who’re also called Bastards of Young. The NYC Bastards have been at it a few years now and obviously have fun with the idea — the patriotically-dressed singer referred to the rest of the band as “Bob,” “Tommy” and “Chris” matching the Mats classic line-up. Though they skipped their namesake song, they zeroing in on great songs mostly from the Bob Stinson era including early single “I’m In Trouble,” “Swinging Party” (which they reminded us about how dark it is), “Can’t Hardly Wait,” “I Will Dare,” “Unsatisfied” and ending with “Black Diamond” (which is a Kiss song that they Replacements recorded, so it’s a cover band doing a cover of the band they’re covering, right?). Listening to their set, I finally understood that “Dare” really is a yearning piece of punk rebellion and age confusion and not just a goofy, country-flavored song. Also, I’m now fully convinced that song for song, the more polished Tim is a much better record than Let It Be and maybe even Pleased To Meet Me is too, consensus be damned.

As Bob Mehr’s great biography of the Mats (Trouble Boys) is soon to be a biopic, their time might be coming again — the NYC Bastards definitely deserve a cameo there. And Tim deserves more love, too.

 

Barking Pumpkins as Smashing Pumpkins (Image: Jason Gross)

2027 LINE-UPS?

After these four great, revelatory, confusing bands, I had my fill for the night. I did stick around briefly to see Barking Pumpkins as Smashing Pumpkins, who wisely started with (and romped through) “Cherub Rock” and that when I ran into the bald singer earlier that night, he was a hell of a lot nicer than Billy C. By that time, the club definitely reached its 120 people capacity. I did regret not sticking around to see the bands doing Ween (which is a hilarious idea), the Police, White Stripes and System of a Down (sadly no reports of GWAR there this time). No regrets about missing the ABBA band though, not even for kitsch value.

Still, I can’t deny that I had a great time, even if I was confused as hell over some of the bands’ identities. Turns out that ‘80s, ‘90s nostalgia caught up to me and no doubt it’ll happen for the millennials as well as Generation Alpha, Beta and the ones that follow. Next time though, I’d love to see the hip NYC acts go more obscure and cover Chokebore, Jellyfish, Dag Nasty, Scratch Acid, Heavenly, Saccharine Trust, Brianiac, Velocity Girl, Unwound, the Delta 72 and Lungfish for their next Halloween showcase. They might not pack ‘em in but it’d be a hoot.

Jason Gross

 You May Also Like

Jason Gross

Jason Gross is the editor/founder of Perfect Sound Forever, one of the first and longest-running online music magazines. He has written for Pitchfork, Rolling Stone, Time Out, AP, New York, MTV, Oxford American, Billboard, MOJO, The Wire, and Blurt. Reissues and collections that he's produced included Delta 5, Essential Logic, Kleenex/Liliput, DNA, Oh OK and OHM –The Early Gurus of Electronic Music. He lives in New York with his girlfriend and 30 plush cats.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *