Bottomless Memories from The Bottom Line

15 years after closing its doors, one regular patron remembers the legendary club

The Bottom Line, NYC

“Right this way, Mr. Bowie. Have a good evening.”

Entering The Bottom Line I was blocked, suddenly, left behind by my friends who were being told not to save seats, while I was stuck in David Bowie’s wake. It was a fleeting moment; what David Letterman would call a “Brush with Greatness.”

When I got to my group to tell them, they were nowhere to be seen. I don’t remember whom I was with and nor who played that night. But we were lined up waiting on Mercer Street, not West 4th like we did for most all other shows.

 The Bottom Line opened on February 11, 1974. I was a Freshman at Syracuse. When home in New York, most days started with The Bottom Line’s WNEW FM’s concert schedule, to the tune of Todd Rundgren’s “Breathless” from Something/Anything? They listed upcoming bands in the weekly Village Voice and SoHo News. I wasn’t there for all of the very best shows. I missed Todd and Bruce, and, because one so-called friend wouldn’t front the money before Thanksgiving break, I didn’t see Hall and Oates. I did see Billy Joel. Memorably, he answered one audience member rhetorically, “Why do I wear a suit and tie when I play? Because I can afford to.” Once he started banging out Angry Young Man, though, I likened it to the crack of the bat, hitting a ball right on the screws straight to the wall. June 8, 1976. $4.50!


VIDEO: Tower of Power Live at The Bottom Line 1977

I spent more evenings with Tower of Power at the Bottom Line than with any other band. This was odd for two reasons. Most important, when Lenny Williams left, they could never be the same without his golden-throated voice. The horns remained “funkified” absent Williams, but couldn’t withstand the loss of “D.G.” David Garibaldi on drums, “C.T.” Mr. Chester Thompson on organ, and, “L.P.” Lenny Pickett. It was like the Yankees losing Bernie Williams, Paul O’Neil, Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera in 1998. When Williams went solo, he scheduled a gig at The Bottom Line with legendary fusion guitarist Eric Gale opening. Williams had to cancel. “And now The Bottom Line is proud to present the Lenny Williams Band.” Oy! This was Christmas night 1977. A week later, Williams was promoting his solo album at a record store across the street from my office. I told him I was bummed that he wasn’t able to perform. He asked, “Why didn’t you come back the next night?” I’d already paid $5.00 not to see him. He wanted me to pay another $5.00. I asked him if he’d put me on the guest list next time if I bought his record. He said no.

The duo I saw as much as Tower of Power at The Bottom Line was Flo and Eddie. One show stands out. New Year’s Day 1982, $10.00. Karla DeVito opened. She was great. Mid set, she said, “And now a special guest, someone who I’ve always wanted to sing backup for. Mis-ter…Lou…Christie!” He ran on stage and she backed him on “Lightning Strikes.” We were all screaming, “…again and again and again and again.” Their act, as the girls on Jamaica Avenue said at that time, was “hellafide.” But Flo and Eddie topped them.  They’d backed up Bruce Springsteen on “Hungry Heart” and, suddenly, we heard the downbeat and sax for the song. Immediately, the audience started singing “Got a wife and kids in Baltimore, Jack,” while Flo and Eddie stood there looking at each other, scratching their heads. When the second verse came around, they sang the background harmonies. They looked at the audience, shaking their heads, saying, “We don’t know the words. We don’t have the album. We’re just backup singers!”

Bruce Springsteen promoting Born to Run and his August shows at the Bottom Line in 1975

Leader of the Pack, January 20, 1984, $11.00, featuring the 1960s hits of Ellie Greenwich and Jeff Barry was the most creative of the shows I went to. An all-star cast that included Karla DeVito, Ula Hedwig, Darlene Love, Paul Schaeffer and others singing the songs written by Greenwich and made popular by Leslie Gore and others. The Times gave it a great write-up, calling it the “Dream Girls of the 1960’s.” 

Uncle Floyd’s Birthday Bash came on my 25th birthday. January 29, 1981, $7.50. Floyd’s brother, Jimmy, arranged all the music, just as he would for Leader of the Pack three years later. Floyd did every song he did on TV, along with most all of his routines, Senator Stunata, Looney Skip Rooney. “We don’t care about the Mets!” was sung early and often. The friend I too was reluctant, something to do before meeting others in Chinatown. When we got downtown, he sheepishly admitted enjoying it. Floyd was uncensored live. Someone baited him from the audience: “Suck my dick, asshole.” Vivino’s return didn’t miss a beat, “If only your mother hadn’t already bitten it off.” I doubt that it was David Bowie who’d heckled Vivino.

The chum who couldn’t shell out for Hall and Oates upfront got free tickets to see Ronnie Earl and The Broadcasters. He worked at WOR. He told me to meet his friend, political pundit, Jay Severin, and his friends outside the West 4th entrance. There was no line. People were entering in dribs and drabs. So I just waited for my friend and figured we’d find them. When my friend came, he asked if Severin got there yet. I didn’t know. As we walked in, Severin and friends were first people he saw. I said, “Oh, that’s what he looks like.” My chum forgot that he worked with Severin at WOR Radio. How could I know his face? As Severin uttered of Earl’s blues riffs, “Testify!”

The Bottom Line closed in 2004.


VIDEO: Todd Rundgren live at The Bottom Line 1978

VIDEO: Brand X live at The Bottom Line 1978

VIDEO: Santana live at The Bottom Line 1978

VIDEO: The Good Rats live at The Bottom Line 1978

VIDEO: The Police live at The Bottom Line 1979

VIDEO: Miles Davis live at The Bottom Line 1975

VIDEO: Hawkwind live at The Bottom Line 1978


VIDEO: Peter Gabriel live at The Bottom Line 1978

 You May Also Like

Billy Sternberg

Billy Sternberg graduated from Syracuse University's Newhouse School. He bought national TV commercial ad time for American Home Products. Their brands ranged from Anacin to Chef Boyardee to Black Flag Roach Motel. After that, he bought national TV time at Ogilvy & Mather for American Express, Kimberly Clark and Owens Corning Fiberglas. Because of this he was gifted many tickets to many events.

3 thoughts on “Bottomless Memories from The Bottom Line

  • June 5, 2019 at 6:19 pm

    Awesome! You brought back memories including memories of things I never actually got to see. A great era, those prices!, and very very little on video/film so who knows? Awaiting your return to the Palladium, CBGB, maybe the Lone Star….! Solid!

    • June 6, 2019 at 1:56 pm

      Thank so much, Adam. It may be they’ll let me do an article combining all three by your request.

  • July 23, 2019 at 2:52 pm

    Either after the 1977 or 1978 Yankees World Series victories over the Dodgers, I saw Chuck Mangione at The Bottom Line. I knew he was a big Yankee fan. And from the corner of my eye while he was playing, I spotted Sparky Lyle heading towards the bathroom. I saw that no one else saw him. I waited a moment and followed him in there even though I didn’t have to go. He finished his business and I extended my hand even before he washed his. But said I was a big fan and it was an unbelievable season. He said, “It really was an unbelievable season.” We may have walked out together. Then after the next song or two, Mangione introduced him to a crowd that went crazy.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *